A Civic Pulse publication
The accountability feed

News

Vetted coverage of Governor Hochul's administration, grouped by day. Every item names its publication and carries a source-credibility tier — Tier 1 primary/wire, Tier 2 established outlet, Tier 3 secondary. No spin; each story links to its original source.

23 items

Oct 14, 2026

1
NBC New YorkTIER 2High

Hochul and Blakeman meet in their only debate: ICE shooting in the Bronx, utility costs, crime statistics and Trump dominate; NBC New York reports no fact-checks of the claims traded

Spectrum News/NY1 debate, Oct. 13, moderated by Errol Louis and Susan Arbetter. Per NBC New York: opened on the ICE shooting of Oscar Belgal in the Bronx. Hochul called ICE out of control and said Blakeman had not condemned it; Blakeman called New York a sanctuary state and Belgal a gangbanger. Hochul attributed higher gas and energy costs to the Iran war and Trump; Blakeman said Hochul, not Trump, raised utility bills 48 times. Hochul said statewide crime is at modern lows; Blakeman cited a report ranking Nassau County safest in America. Blakeman said he is pro-choice, called Trump a friend and did not disavow his endorsement; Blakeman tied Hochul to Mayor Mamdani. Statistics were stated by the candidates and not independently checked in the NBC recap. Not yet fact-checked in this tracker.

Sep 23, 2026

1
New York Public News Network via WAMC (Jon Campbell)TIER 2High

Backfill: Uber is the sole funder of a second pro-Hochul super PAC, Fair and Affordable New York, which put $1M into a family-themed TV ad after a $3M Uber deposit; Uber's pro-Hochul spending tops $13M since January

Per BOE records cited by WNYC/Gothamist, Uber put $3M into Fair and Affordable New York in late August; the PAC spent $1M on an ad in early September. This is separate from Citizens for Affordable Rates, Uber's earlier vehicle tied to the auto-insurance changes in the budget. Published Sept. 10; missed by prior refreshes.

Sep 22, 2026

1
New York Public News Network via WAMC (Jon Campbell)TIER 2High

Hochul and Blakeman set their only debate for Oct. 13, hosted by Spectrum News and broadcast live on its statewide affiliates and YouTube; comptroller candidates debate Oct. 1 and attorney general candidates Oct. 8

Spectrum News announced Sept. 22 that Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) and Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman (R) will meet Oct. 13 in the first and only gubernatorial debate before the Nov. 3 election. Down-ballot: comptroller debate Oct. 1, attorney general debate Oct. 8.

Sep 19, 2026

2
Spectrum News (Keegan Trunick); Governor's office statementTIER 2High

State reaches $24M settlement with the family of Robert Brooks, beaten to death by correction officers at Marcy in Dec. 2024; Hochul: "Robert Brooks should be alive today," pledges DOCCS facilities will be "fully reformed"

On Sept. 18 the state settled with the family of Robert Brooks, 43, of Rochester, for $24 million (figure from the governor's office, per Spectrum). Brooks died Dec. 10, 2024, hours after arriving at Marcy Correctional Facility, from neck compression and internal injuries; the medical examiner ruled it a homicide and body-camera footage released by the AG showed officers beating him while restrained. More than a dozen prison employees were fired; multiple officers were convicted or pleaded, two were acquitted at trial. Hochul's statement: "No family should ever have to endure what the family of Robert Brooks has been through... Robert Brooks should be alive today. Every individual who enters a DOCCS facility deserves to be safe, and I am committed to continuing to do everything in my power to ensure our correctional facilities are fully reformed and safe for all." Context for the race: the Brooks killing preceded the 2025 wildcat correction officers' strike and the firings that NYSCOPBA cited this week in its first-ever statewide endorsement, for Blakeman (Sept. 17). No promise-tracker row covers DOCCS reform, so this is logged as news only.

National Law Review (Beveridge & Diamond client alert, Sept. 18)TIER 2High

Climate Superfund case moves toward appeal: New York and the challengers jointly ask Judge Sannes for a Rule 54(b) final judgment and an injunction barring the state from enforcing the $75B law, with remaining claims held pending a 2nd Circuit appeal

First procedural movement since the Aug. 31 ruling. On Sept. 14 (the court's status-report deadline in West Virginia v. James), attorneys for the state and the plaintiffs jointly asked the N.D.N.Y. to (1) enter a declaratory judgment that the Climate Change Superfund Act is preempted, (2) enjoin New York officials from implementing or enforcing it, (3) enter final judgment under Rule 54(b) on the two preemption claims, and (4) administratively close the case and hold the unresolved constitutional claims (Commerce Clause, Due Process, Equal Protection, Excessive Fines, Takings) in abeyance pending appeal. A 54(b) judgment is what lets the state take an immediate appeal to the 2nd Circuit; no notice of appeal has been reported yet. Implementation of the law is effectively on hold. The appeal would run alongside Suncor v. Boulder County, which the Supreme Court hears Oct. 5, 2026 on the same federal-preemption question. Accountability watch: whether AG James files the notice of appeal after judgment is entered, and how the state replaces the $75B in its resilience math if it loses.

Sep 18, 2026

1
WXXI News (Beth Adams)TIER 2High

Blakeman in Greece (Rochester): says he would sign an "emergency order" lifting the fracking ban to cut utility rates in half, calls the POWER checks "an election year trick," and says he opposes large-scale solar on farmland and offshore wind

Second day of the same message, new mechanism on record: at a Sept. 18 campaign stop in Greece, Monroe County, Blakeman said Hochul's $100-$200 POWER checks are "a scheme, and it's election year trick" after utility bills rose "700 to $1,000 or more" a year (campaign figure, unverified here). He vowed to cut utility rates in half by signing an emergency order to lift the state's fracking ban, and said he opposes large-scale solar arrays on agricultural land and offshore wind projects. WXXI notes NYISO attributes rate pressure to natural-gas prices, aging infrastructure and tightening supply, and that the fracking ban was codified in state law in 2020 after a DEC review. See fact check on whether an executive order can lift a statutory ban.

Sep 17, 2026

1
Chalkbeat New York (Alex Zimmerman)TIER 2High

Teachers unions and the NAACP press Hochul to "opt out right now" of the federal tax-credit scholarship she plans to join in 2027; her office says she still supports it and is waiting on Treasury rules due this month to check for "poison pills"

At UFT headquarters on Sept. 16, AFT president Randi Weingarten, UFT president Michael Mulgrew, NYSUT president Melinda Person, lawmakers and NAACP representatives urged Hochul to reverse the plan she announced in May (first to Agudath Israel) to opt New York into the federal tax-credit scholarship created by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. The program, effective January 2027, gives donors a dollar-for-dollar federal credit up to $1,700 for gifts to scholarship-granting organizations that can fund private tuition, tutoring and other costs; governors must opt in. Unions launched a petition and argue private schools can pick students and that families up to 300% of area median income qualify. Hochul spokesperson Jonah Allon said the governor wants the credit "to benefit all New York students" and noted it does not draw on state or local budgets; a Sept. 10 letter from 37 anti-poverty groups and charter leaders backs opting in. Thirty states have opted in per the IRS; Colorado's Jared Polis is the only Democratic governor to do so. Most groups at the rally support Hochul's reelection.

Sep 11, 2026

2
La Voce di New York / The HillTIER 2High

The ceremony happened without incident: Mamdani attended Ground Zero as planned, shook hands with Giuliani on arrival, and no turned backs or protest were reported; Hochul, Vance, Bush, Clinton, Obama and Biden were in the elected-officials section

After a week in which Blakeman, Giuliani and Pataki urged Mamdani to stay away (Blakeman suggested attendees "turn their back on the mayor"), the 25th-anniversary reading of 2,753 names went ahead with the mayor and governor present. Footage shows Mamdani approaching Giuliani and the two shaking hands; Mamdani later said they exchanged pleasantries and kept the focus on families. No elected official spoke, consistent with the Memorial's post-2012 rule. Trump was at the Pentagon after reportedly being refused a speaking slot. Relevance to the governor's race: the walkout/protest Blakeman floated did not materialize, and Hochul's "voices of hatred should not prevail" line was not tested by any disruption. Secondary source: thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/6084719-mamdani-and-giuliani-shake-hands-at-9-11-commemoration/

City & State (Sophie Krichevsky)TIER 2High

Three firefighter unions endorse Hochul on the anniversary: UFA, UFOA and the NYS Professional Fire Fighters Association cite the revived September 11th Worker Protection Task Force and Tier 3/Tier 6 pension reforms in this year's budget

The Uniformed Firefighters Association (Bobby Eustace), Uniformed Fire Officers Association (James Brosi) and NYSPFFA (Sam Fresina) issued a joint statement backing Hochul for reelection, released exclusively to City & State at 5am on Sept. 11. They point to the reconstituted 9/11 Worker Protection Task Force and the Tier 3 and Tier 6 retirement changes in the FY27 budget. Context from C&S: UFA and UFOA also endorsed Hochul in 2022, NYSPFFA's political arm spent on her then, and all three are affiliates of the state AFL-CIO, which endorsed her July 1 over TWU objections. Timing matters more than novelty: the endorsement lands the same day Blakeman had urged 9/11 families and first responders to shun the governor and mayor at Ground Zero.

Sep 8, 2026

1
Fingerlakes1.com (campaign release)TIER 2High

Blakeman campaign releases a McLaughlin internal showing Hochul 49.6, Blakeman 45.7 among 800 likely voters (Aug 27-31); release omits margin of error, mode and question wording

On Sept. 8 the Blakeman campaign released a McLaughlin & Associates survey of 800 likely voters fielded Aug. 27-31: Hochul 49.6%, Blakeman 45.7%, undecided 4.7%. The campaign called the 3.9-point gap inside the margin of error but did not publish a numerical MOE, survey mode, weighting or question order. Other toplines from the release: Hochul 42/55 favorable/unfavorable, Blakeman 40/30 with 30% unfamiliar; 56% "time for someone new" vs 38% "deserves reelection"; among the 80% who said they knew both candidates, Blakeman led 52-44 (threshold undefined). Context: this is a campaign-sponsored poll from a Republican firm. The most recent independent poll, Siena Aug 3-6 LV, had Hochul 49-39; a Democratic-aligned Concord/ERN poll Aug 19-21 had 50-34. Logged in the polls table flagged is_partisan. No Hochul campaign response in the release.

Sep 4, 2026

1
Inside Climate NewsTIER 2High

Federal judge strikes down the Climate Change Superfund Act: NDNY Chief Judge Sannes rules the $75B polluter-pays law is preempted by the Clean Air Act; Hochul says the state is "looking" at "options of appeal"

On Monday Aug. 31, Chief U.S. District Judge Brenda Sannes (N.D.N.Y.) granted summary judgment to 22 Republican-led states, the American Petroleum Institute, the U.S. Chamber and the Business Council of New York State, holding that the Climate Change Superfund Act (signed by Hochul Dec. 26, 2024; $75B over 25 years from fossil-fuel companies) operates in an area where federal interest is so dominant it cannot be enforced, relying on the 2nd Circuit's 2021 City of New York v. Chevron ruling. Hochul told reporters the state is "looking" at its "options of appeal"; her energy adviser Ken Lovett said taxpayers should not foot the bill for polluters and the decision is under review. Sponsor Sen. Liz Krueger said the AG "needs to appeal" and that losing shifts roughly $75B in planned resilience costs to taxpayers. The Business Council and Upstate United called the law an overreach; DOJ's Adam Gustafson said the ruling delivers on Trump's April 2025 order against state "overreach." A separate DOJ suit against the law is pending in S.D.N.Y., a Vermont challenge is pending, and the Supreme Court hears Suncor v. Boulder County in October on the same preemption question. Any appeal goes to the 2nd Circuit. Backfill: ruling landed Aug. 31, reported Sept. 1, missed by the Sept. 1–3 runs.

Sep 3, 2026

1
ABC7 New YorkTIER 2High

Hochul answers Blakeman on the headscarf: "that says more about him than it does anybody else"; office cites 2022 Ronkonkoma mosque visit and Officer Islam's funeral as precedent

Hochul's first direct on-camera response to the headscarf pile-on: "I was invited as a guest, and I always wear the appropriate attire, whether I am going to a temple... an Orthodox community or... a catholic church in the Vatican." On Blakeman's Newsday remark that wearing a hijab and calling herself a feminist are incompatible: "I just love it when men lecture women on whether or not they are a feminist." Her office pointed to prior head coverings at a 2022 Ronkonkoma mosque that had been attacked and at the funeral of NYPD Officer Didarul Islam. Blakeman said his post was not an attack on Muslims and that he visits mosques regularly as county executive. CAIR-NY's Afaf Nasher said tying the visit to 9/11 is inappropriate. The visit was Friday Aug 28 at the Islamic Cultural Center of New York on the Upper East Side.

Sep 2, 2026

3
CBS New YorkTIER 2High

DHS fires back at Hochul: FEMA says New York is "manufacturing a funding crisis" while sitting on $300M+ in unspent homeland-security money

The federal response to the Sept. 1 Hochul-Mamdani demand for $87M in withheld counterterrorism funds arrived the same evening. The White House referred CBS New York to DHS, and a FEMA spokesperson said Hochul is "manufacturing a funding crisis despite New York sitting on more than $300 million in UNSPENT federal homeland security funding," adding that New York has historically received allocations "significantly ABOVE risk-based formulas." The statement did not dispute that $87M of the $187M Trump said he would restore in October 2025 has not been sent. The $300M unspent figure is a DHS/FEMA characterization; the state has not published a reconciliation and we have not independently verified it (see fact_checks). Separately, CBS pressed Hochul on whether an undocumented immigrant with a DWI conviction should be able to stay; she declined a yes/no, saying enforcement should prioritize assaults, murders, rapes and burglaries and that she would "look at the circumstances of an individual case."

MediaiteTIER 2High

Trump joins the headscarf pile-on: Truth Social post calls Hochul "the Worst Governor in the Country," says she wears "the hijab" to get "the Arab Vote"

On Sept. 1 President Trump posted the Aug. 28 photo of Hochul in a black headscarf at the Islamic Cultural Center School in the Bronx, wrote that Hochul, "considered the Worst Governor in the Country," was "working hard to get the Arab Vote," tied it to congestion pricing hurting her "especially [with] the people for whom she wears the hijab," and closed: "The whole thing is CRAZY!" It escalates the four-day-old controversy from conservative influencers and members of Congress to the president, three weeks after Trump boosted Blakeman at a law-enforcement rally. Hochul's office has said she wore the headscarf as a gesture of respect, consistent with past practice, and that she respects 9/11 victims while rejecting anti-Muslim hatred. Snopes rated the "wore a hijab" framing a Mixture because her hair was visible.

New York Jewish Week / JTATIER 2High

Blakeman posts the headscarf photo, calls it "political pandering" and "tone-deaf" before 9/11; Jewish Council for Public Affairs CEO calls his post Islamophobia

Blakeman's first public entry into the headscarf story: a social-media post depicting Hochul in the head covering, accusing her of "political pandering" he called "especially tone-deaf" less than two weeks before the 25th anniversary of 9/11. Amy Spitalnick, CEO of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs, responded on X: "There are far too many political leaders exploiting the 9/11 anniversary to (re)normalize Islamophobia — and it's disgusting." Blakeman, who is Jewish, has campaigned heavily on antisemitism and public safety. The same JTA item notes Hochul's campaign has her at a MET Council Rosh Hashanah food-distribution event in Brooklyn on Sept. 2 with Comptroller Mark Levine and Council Member Lincoln Restler. Blakeman's post is documented only through JTA's account; the post itself was not retrieved for this entry.

Sep 1, 2026

1
Fox NewsTIER 2High

Retired Port Authority officers ask Hochul to skip the 25th-anniversary Ground Zero ceremony; she says she will attend

The Retired Port Authority Police Benevolent Association, through president John McDevitt, sent letters on Aug. 14 asking Gov. Hochul and Mayor Mamdani not to attend the Sept. 11 25th-anniversary ceremony at Ground Zero, saying their presence would inflict "deep pain" on victims' families, survivors and first responders. The group's stated objection to Hochul is her decision to light One World Trade Center for Muslim American Heritage Month — it says it did not object to the proclamation itself, only to using the World Trade Center site for the observance. The letters surfaced publicly Aug. 29. Hochul rejected the demand and says she will attend; Mamdani also plans to attend. The dispute feeds directly into the separate backlash over the Aug. 28 headscarf clip, with both threads now tied to the Sept. 11 anniversary ten days out.

Aug 18, 2026

1
WBEN / AudacyTIER 2High

Backfill: EPA relocated four Town of Niagara families on July 18 after readings up to 900,000 counts per second; families say housing was not ready

On a July 18, 2026 call with EPA and Hochul administration officials, four Town of Niagara households (Hawk/Bradley, Johnson, Linkowski, Motyka) were told they would be relocated the same day after testing found high radioactive contamination; Geiger readings in one backyard measured as high as 900,000 counts per second. The homeowners said EPA then asked them to find their own housing for at least a week, and one family was told moving costs would not be covered. In a statement the families said staffing was inadequate (one DEC and one EPA screener) and called on Governor Hochul and the Trump administration to stand up emergency and State Superfund teams. Published July 20, 2026; backfilled to close a gap between the July 14 Hochul letter and the August coverage.

Aug 6, 2026

1
WAMC / NCPR / CBS6 AlbanyTIER 2High

287(g) compliance splits upstate counties: Rensselaer defies wind-down order as St. Lawrence unwinds and Saratoga sheriff backs lawsuit

With the Aug. 25 deadline to terminate 287(g) ICE agreements under the Local Cops, Local Crimes Act approaching — and the NDNY ruling upholding the state ban now in hand — the 12 affected agencies are splitting. St. Lawrence County's sheriff says his agreement is "dead in the water" (NCPR, Aug. 5). Rensselaer County Executive Steve McLaughlin and Sheriff Kyle Bourgault say they will not comply ("I will defy you"), drawing resident backlash at a county meeting (CBS6). Saratoga County's sheriff backs a planned lawsuit against the state ban (WAMC, Aug. 4). Nassau's written response is still due Aug. 14. The compliance split sets up the next test of the law Hochul and AG James are enforcing.

Aug 4, 2026

1
Spectrum News / Courthouse NewsTIER 2High

Federal judge splits ruling on NY immigration laws: mask ban for ICE agents blocked, 287(g) agreement ban upheld

U.S. District Judge Mae D'Agostino (NDNY) ruled Monday evening, Aug. 3, on the DOJ's challenge to the immigration measures Hochul signed in May. She granted a preliminary injunction against the provisions barring federal agents from wearing masks and requiring visible identification, finding they likely interfere with federal law enforcement operations. She denied the injunction against the ban on 287(g) agreements, siding with the state that it is "an appropriate means of furthering New York's legitimate interests." Hochul and AG James said they are reviewing legal options on the mask ban while calling the 287(g) portion a win. The upheld ban directly bears on Nassau's Aug. 25 wind-down deadline.

Aug 3, 2026

1
WSHU / NY Public News NetworkTIER 2High

Medical Aid in Dying law takes effect Aug. 5 as courts split: Catholic plaintiffs win consent injunction, disability-rights suit dismissed

New York's Medical Aid in Dying law, signed by Hochul on Dec. 17, 2025 after more than a decade of legislative debate, takes effect Wednesday, Aug. 5. Two court rulings landed this week: the state agreed to a temporary injunction and restraining order exempting the Catholic plaintiffs — four orders of religious nuns, the Diocese of Rockville Centre, and other Catholic facilities — from complying while their First Amendment suit proceeds (order applies only to parties in the case). Separately, a federal judge on Thursday dismissed a suit from individual plaintiffs and disability-rights advocates alleging ADA violations, finding they lacked standing. Under the law, patients with six months or less to live can obtain life-ending medication after meeting statutory conditions.

Jul 30, 2026

1
NY Post via AlgemeinerTIER 2High

Pro-Blakeman super PAC poll shows race at 47-43; public polling last had Hochul up 20

A Red Oak Strategic poll commissioned by the pro-Blakeman "Strong and Safe" super PAC — a previously unreported committee — puts Hochul at 47%, Blakeman 43%, 10% undecided among 2,000 registered voters surveyed Jul 7-12 (MOE ±2.2). It also reports Hochul approval at 39/56 and Blakeman leading independents 54-33. The partisan-sponsored numbers contrast sharply with Siena's June public poll, which had Hochul up 52-32.

Jul 25, 2026

1
Buffalo NewsTIER 2High

Hochul campaign refunds 500+ donations totaling more than $1.7M, including checks from WNY executives and Melinda French Gates

Buffalo News reported (circa Jul 22) that Hochul's re-election campaign refunded more than 500 donations totaling over $1.7M, including sizable contributions from high-profile Western New York business executives and Melinda French Gates. The specific reason for each refund was not stated in accessible reporting; New York's general-election contribution limit is $18,000, and the campaign has previously refunded donations from state appointees under the executive-order ban. Article also notes Blakeman reported $4.6M on hand at the start of July vs. Hochul's $21M. Full article is paywalled; details limited to the published lede.

Jul 15, 2026

1
Empire Report / Friends for Kathy HochulTIER 2High

Hochul announces $17M July filing haul: $5.6M to campaign, $11.4M to state party, $20M+ cash on hand

On the July 15 BOE periodic filing deadline, Hochul's campaign announced raising $17M this period: $5.6M to Friends for Kathy Hochul from a claimed record 27,000 unique donors (avg online donation $20) and $11.4M into the NYS Democratic Party. Campaign says it ends the period with $20M+ cash on hand; the state party with $22M+ (combined $42M). Figures are campaign-announced — itemized BOE disclosure data not yet independently reviewed. No Blakeman July numbers announced as of this run.