MTA left to absorb $200 million city bus-subsidy cut from the May budget deal
As part of the $4 billion in gap-closing help for New York City that Hochul and Mayor Mamdani announced May 12, 2026, the city reduced its FY2027 operating subsidy for MTA Bus by $200 million, one time. The city's May financial plan labeled the amount "State Aid for MTA," and the city and state comptrollers described it as a cost shifting to the state. The city comptroller said in June the change was not in the state's enacted budget, and the MTA's July financial plan says the reduction "will be covered by MTA resources." Reinvent Albany laid this out in a Nov. 16 report; Streetsblog, the New York Post and Bloomberg covered it the same day. The governor's office says bus service is unaffected. The MTA board meets Nov. 18 with an updated financial plan due. The underlying budget documents have not been read directly for this entry. Update Nov. 16, 2026: Hochul told amNewYork the report mischaracterized the arrangement and that the state has filled the hole, citing "structural changes in the longer-term pension benefits," and added: "The money's there, the work's continuing. Everybody can calm down." She did not detail in those remarks how the pension changes offset the $200 million. Mamdani's office did not respond to amNewYork.
The case on each side
Hochul spokesperson Sean Butler told the New York Post that "No Governor has stepped up to support the MTA and its riders like Governor Hochul" and that the one-time reduction in the city's FY2027 subsidy "was part of a comprehensive package to address the City's deficit and has zero impact on bus service for New Yorkers." The MTA's July plan likewise says the reduction is covered by MTA resources and service levels are maintained. Hochul herself told amNewYork on Nov. 16 that the state "made some other structural changes in the longer-term pension benefits" and that "the money's there."
Reinvent Albany calls it a backdoor raid on dedicated transit money: the city's own plan and both comptrollers described the $200 million as state-funded, nothing in the state budget bills provided for it, and the MTA ended up covering it. The group sets the amount against the $142 million the MTA expects in 2027 from a 4% fare increase on city buses and subways, and points to the state's $87.3 billion cash balance. Rachael Fauss of Reinvent Albany said it is "unfair for riders to have a higher burden" and that the governor should "make the MTA whole." Fauss responded to the governor: "State aid is funding; it's not some backdoor mechanism where the MTA eats the cost." Betsy Plum of Riders Alliance said the move "makes New York less affordable and erodes trust in our government."